Algonquin Power Income Fund (TSX: APF-U, OTC: AGQNF) and Crescent Point Energy Trust (TSX: CPG-U, OTC: CPGCF) have joined AG Growth International (TSX: AFN, OTC: AGGZF), Bonterra Oil & Gas (TSX: BNE, OTC: BNEFF) and Superior Plus Corp (TSX: SPB, OTC: SUUIF) in the growing group of trusts announcing corporate conversions without simultaneously reducing distributions.
Algonquin slashed its distribution nearly 70 percent last October. At the time, my feeling was this was basically preparing for an early conversion. Management’s official statement was it was saving cash for growth.
As it turned out, both assertions proved true. Management has spent more on growth, most recently via a USD116 million 50-50 joint venture with Emera (TSX: EMA, OTC: EMRAF) to purchase the 47,000 customer California operations of NV Energy (NYSE: NVE). The dividend, meanwhile, was lowered enough to make it easily sustainable under a corporate structure.
Even counting Algonquin, “no-cut” conversions have been dramatically outnumbered by those involving reductions. Critically, however, market reaction to no-cut conversions has been highly favorable, particularly compared to conversions with dividend cuts.
I detect two clear reasons for this. One is investors like dividends. And while trusts that have cut during their conversions have eventually attracted more growth-focused investors, the cuts have initially triggered a disruptive mass exodus from their shares. That’s at least temporarily shut down their ability to raise equity capital at non-dilutive rates.
Advantage Energy Income Fund (TSX: AVN-U, NYSE: AAV), for example, eliminated its distribution in March as part of an early conversion to a corporation. And its CAD102 million equity sale in late June came off at just 60 percent of book value and less than half net asset value. The fact that it was forced to accept such a paltry sum is a real warning of weakness--i.e., that it truly needs cash--despite some recent recovery in the share price.
more